🏛️Library of Alexandria🏛️

[TheOS » More than ONE meaning: Tied together.]



More than ONE meaning: Tied together.

April 25, 2025 at 8:43 pm
Aisopose

Ancient Greek–language authors (think the Septuagint translators, Philo of Alexandria, Origen, the Church Fathers writing in Greek, and before them Homer, Hesiod, Plato) routinely wove multiple levels of meaning into a single narrative. They didn’t see “literal vs. symbolic” as an either/or, but as nested dimensions of truth—what you’re calling a 5-D consciousness.

Below is a way to articulate that framework:


1. Five “Dimensions” of Greek Narrative

DimensionAncient Greek Term / AnalogyWhat It Does
1. Literal (ἱστορικός)Histōr (investigator)The “surface” story—events as they happened.
2. Moral (τρόπος / τροπικός)Tropoi (turns, tropes)Ethical lessons—how ought I to live?
3. Allegorical (ἀλληγορικός)Allēgoria (speaking otherwise)Doctrinal truths—what does it teach about God, Christ, the Church?
4. Anagogical (ἀναγωγικός)Anagōgē (ascent)Eschatological/spiritual ascent—where is the soul headed?
5. Mystical / Cosmic (θεολογικός)Theologia (word about the divine)Hidden, esoteric patterns—cycles of nature, seasons, cosmic rhythms.

Note: Medieval Latin scholars formalized the first four “senses” of Scripture; here we’ve added a 5th Greek-style “mystical/cosmic” layer to capture the way Greek myth and philosophy always pointed to patterns in nature (seasons, star cycles, math harmonies).


2. Why “Conceptual” Doesn’t Deny the “Literal”

  1. Layers Build, They Don’t Cancel
    • A story can be “historical enough” at level 1 while pointing at moral lessons (2), Christ‐types (3), heavenly destiny (4), and cosmic cycles (5).
    • Example: The Exodus may record an actual migration, but it’s also:
      • (2) A call to justice (“let my people go”).
      • (3) A foreshadowing of baptism in Christ.
      • (4) A picture of the soul’s journey to God.
      • (5) A cosmic pattern of death–rebirth (solar/seasonal imagery in the Red Sea crossing).
  2. Greeks Never “Only” Did One
    • In Homer the same line can describe Achilles’ rage (literal) and hint at the unrest in every human heart (moral), the tension between order and chaos (allegorical), the soul’s longing for home (anagogical), and the churning of the elements (mystical).
  3. “Conceptual” = pointing past the page, not erasing it
    • To call something “conceptual” is simply to say that the author intended you to recognize patterns, symbols, cycles.
    • The literal gives you the hook; the conceptual gives you the scaffolding that holds the whole edifice of theology, ethics, eschatology, and cosmic philosophy.

3. Illustrative Example: Genesis 1 “Day” Structure

DayLiteral EventMoral / TropologicalAllegoricalAnagogicalMystical / Cosmic
1Light createdDarkness vs. clarity in lifeChrist the LightFirst step toward heavenSunrise/sunset cycle; duality of day-night (2-fold)
2Firmament (sky) formedBoundaries in the soulBaptismal watersAscent above chaosWaters above/waters below—two “levels” in cosmos
3Land and vegetation appearBecoming fruitfulThe Church bearing fruitGroundedness in the divineEarth emerges—stable platform; triadic growth
4Sun, moon, and stars setOrder in time and disciplineChrist as Sun; Church and saints as moon/starsCelestial guidance toward eternityCosmic calendar; fourfold time cycles
5Birds and fish createdMultiplying blessings / callingEvangelists (birds) and missionaries (fish)Soul learning to move through realmsDual-realm creatures; breath and depths
6Land animals and man madeMastery of instincts / vocationChrist as true ManFinal preparation for divine unionMicrocosm of creation; sixth stage of labor
7RestSabbath rest for our soulsChrist’s completed workEternal Sabbath in heavenPerfect cycle closure (7 = cosmic perfection)
  1. Surface (1): Yes, light literally appears.
  2. Moral (2): You learn to choose good over evil.
  3. Allegorical (3): Christ as “Light of the world.”
  4. Anagogical (4): Your spirit rests in divine presence.
  5. Cosmic (5): The seven-day pattern mirrors lunar/solar cycles and sets the rhythm for human time.

4. How to Explain It to Skeptics

  1. Use a Simple Metaphor
    • “Bible = onion”: peel away layer by layer. You can eat the outer layer, but there’s flavor in the deeper layers.
    • Each peel doesn’t make the outer vanish—it enriches it.
  2. Show That All Cultures Read This Way
    • Even modern movies (e.g. The Matrix):
      • Plot (literal sci-fi chase).
      • Character arc (moral journey).
      • Symbolism (allegory of rebirth).
      • Philosophy (anagogical invitation to transcend).
      • Easter eggs (mystical/cosmic hints at hidden lore).
  3. Demonstrate in a Short Passage
    • Pick a well-known verse (e.g. Psalm 23, “The Lord is my Shepherd…”).
    • Show each level in two minutes: “You can read it as a simple promise, but also as an ethical guide, a picture of Christ caring for His Church, an invitation to heavenly rest, and—if you notice—the shepherd motif mirrors the Greek cosmic shepherd (Ursa Major as a star pattern).”
  4. Invite Them to Try the 5-D Exercise
    • Read a paragraph: check off the five layers.
    • Literal: Who? What? When?
    • Moral: What lesson?
    • Allegory: What larger truth?
    • Anagogical: Where does this point my soul?
    • Mystical: What natural or cosmic pattern echoes here?

In Sum

  • Greek writers thought in nested layers, not isolated levels.
  • Literal doesn’t exclude symbolic—it’s the anchor that allows the deeper “dimensions” to unfold.
  • By framing their method as 5-D consciousness (surface → moral → doctrinal → eschatological → cosmic), you give people a map rather than a fork-in-the-road choice between “real” and “imaginary.”
  • Once they see how Greek myth, Plato, Homer, and early Christian exegesis all use the same approach, they’ll realize the Bible is simply another expression of that rich, multi-layered tradition.

That should help you show them that asking “did it happen?” misses the point—all good stories in the Greek mode happen on many levels at once.